Life around Fernandina Beach feels like a seaside rhythm you never want to disrupt. If you’re a responsible, low-risk driver with great credit and a solid driving history, you deserve auto insurance that reflects the way you live: thoughtful, well-rounded, and priced fairly.

At Barefoot Insurance Brokers, we help preferred drivers across Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island, Yulee, and throughout the State of Florida find quality personal auto insurance with coverage that actually makes sense for their lifestyle and assets.

What Preferred Drivers Around Fernandina Beach Can Get Covered

We’ll help you build a policy that can include:

Liability Coverage
Protection if you’re responsible for damage or injury to others.

Uninsured / Underinsured Motorist Coverage
Extra peace of mind when another driver has little or no insurance.

Physical Damage Coverage
Comprehensive and Collision to help protect your vehicle investment.

Florida-Required PIP (Personal Injury Protection)
Covers certain medical expenses and related costs after an accident.

And for many of our preferred clients, we also talk about adding a Personal Umbrella Policy. Think of it as an extra layer of financial protection that sits above your auto liability limits to help safeguard your home, savings, and future earnings if a serious accident ever leads to a larger claim or lawsuit. It’s an affordable way to protect high-value assets.

Local Agents. Real Conversations. Florida Expertise.

Our team works with top-rated carriers for preferred Florida drivers, including:

Travelers • Mercury • GEICO • Progressive • a Farmers Insurance product • an Allstate Insurance product • and more

We shop the market for you, pairing great coverage with pricing that respects your low-risk profile.

Ready to talk with a Florida-based, English-speaking agent?

We’d love to help you feel confident about your coverage while keeping your rates competitive.

Barefoot Insurance Brokers — serving Fernandina Beach and surrounding areas.
Let’s build a policy that fits your life.

About the Author

Laurel Schwartz is a Licensed Personal Lines Independent Insurance Agent with Barefoot Insurance Brokers, known for her expertise in flood insurance, homeowners insurance, personal umbrella coverage, and auto insurance. Laurel has a strong talent for problem-solving and specializes in helping clients navigate harder-to-place auto risks, including FR-44, SR-22, and other non-standard circumstances. She’s committed to finding solutions where others can’t. You can reach Laurel directly at laurel@barefootins.com or call/text 561-290-1207 for personalized support and expert advice.